WTF are you arguing mamma ?
You said ....
everyone in this thread is operating on their own definition of communism,
I proceeded to proved my point by giving you the
DEFINITION AND HISTORY of Communism
and you argue back with ....
Quite a lot of non-material analysis wrought of a very limited understanding of communism.
non-material analysis ?????
Where did you get this one from? debate club ???
My friend go read a book in
What communism is and
where the idea come from NOT WHAT YOU HEARD FROM YOUR NEIGHBOUR, perhaps after, you would be able to argue your point with some validity, I recommend "The Communist Manifesto" to start and then after you get the grasp read 'THE RISE AND FALL OF COMMUNISM" it will give you a good handle on the subject.
you further slam the pie in your face with ...
China and Russia began as agrarian states and became industrial powers within decades.
Yeah they did; AFTER THEY MOVE INTO CAPITALISM. I'm not gonna argue the movement had some validity at a certain point in History, but as a policy in 2021 is nothing more than an utopic state, a failed policy, a good experiment to place under "
nice try boy"
you further argue stupid shit by quoting one word in the whole paragraph
is not the ONE WORD but the whole statement , Why can't you argue against the idea? you picked one word, ALA GOP; because the statement got you defeated. if you are gonna argue communism use Fidelism or Russian techniques NOT Republican tactics isn't that detrimental in your arguing ?
as for ...
none of them "moved from communism to socialism an eventually to capitalist societies"
the proof is in the pudding ....
Officially there are only five
communist countries still in existence.
Vietnam,
China,
Cuba,
Laos, and
North Korea.
VIETNAM - ONE SHORT LIVED COMUNIST COUNTRY The CPV espouses Marxism–Leninism and Hồ Chí Minh Thought, Vietnam's shift from a centrally planned to
a market economy has transformed the country from one of the poorest in the world into a lower middle-income country. Vietnam now is one of the most dynamic emerging countries in East Asia region.
CHINA - AFTER THE The Great Chinese Famine
( 三年大饥荒) The CCP moved towards a more
market based economy. China has been the world's fastest growing economy for the last 30 years (10% or more per year). It is now the world's second largest economy, (capitalism hidden under the communist tittle) We can best describe China as a Communist country with a veneer of market economics or a capitalist country with a nominally Communist government
CUBA - SAME FAILED STORY AFTER 50 YEARS OF CRAP Cuba has had a
socialist political system since 1959 based on the "one state – one party" principle. Cuba is constitutionally defined as a Marxist–Leninist
socialist state The Cuban state claims to adhere to socialist principles. Recent years have seen a trend toward more private sector employment. By 2006, public sector employment was 78% and private sector 22%, compared to 91.8% to 8.2% in 1981.
LAOS - ANOTHER FAIL ATTEMPT The communist government of Laos was backed by both Vietnam and the Soviet Union. The country especially relied on the support of the Soviet Union for military and economic aid, up until the Union's collapse in 1991. Nowadays
Laos relies on trade with its neighbors Thailand, Vietnam and China.
NORTH KOREA OUTPACED WHO ???? The Democratic People's Republic of Korea (DPRK, also known as North Korea) is a highly centralized
totalitarian state. is one of poorest countries in the world, it's latest GDP growth available from 2018 was −4.1%
As for the USSR the original failed state
IN RUSSIA - COMMUNISM FAILED AFTER 80 YEARS OF BULLSHIT Russia is a very large and diverse country. From 1922 to 1991, it used to be the main part of
the Soviet Union. It was a country based on Communism, but today its government is
a federal semi-presidential republic with elements of democracy.
So You see MOFO
NOOOO COMUNISM, Just a failed bull shit idea used by morons to bring fear into the hearts of the uninformed
Just In Case : Market economy an economic system in which production and prices are determined by unrestricted competition between privately owned businesses. Yeah moron the bases of
Capitalism
by the way
getting your history from Red Dawn
Red Dawn is a 1984 movie that follows a group of American high school students who resist the occupation with guerrilla warfare, naming themselves the "Wolverines", after their high school mascot. - Although the plot is a defense against a communist invasion NO COMMUNIST IDEOLOGY IS DISCUSSED OR HISTORY GIVEN IN THE MOVIE - same for the 2012 movie
Am I the one linking youtube kids shows ????
HMMM