Looks are always subjective.
What is a ten girl to one guy might not be appealing to another. For example people, women as well as men, rave about how beautiful Angelina Jolie is facially. I don't find her beautiful at all.
I'm sure some women I like the look of, an 8 to 10 face and body, would not be seen as such by others. Way of the world.
Lets not forget that although a guys looks are not as important to women as a rule, the subjective element of them viewing us as handsome or less so is just as applicable.